Nico's Cajun Island
  • Photos
  • Menu
  • Location
  • Work Hours
  • Business info
  • Reviews

Nico's Cajun Island Menu

Menu Nico's Cajun Island-1
Menu Nico's Cajun Island-1
Menu Nico's Cajun Island-2
Menu Nico's Cajun Island-2
Menu Nico's Cajun Island-3
Menu Nico's Cajun Island-3
Menu Nico's Cajun Island-4
Menu Nico's Cajun Island-4
Menu Nico's Cajun Island-5
Menu Nico's Cajun Island-5
Menu Nico's Cajun Island-6
Menu Nico's Cajun Island-6
Menu Nico's Cajun Island-7
Menu Nico's Cajun Island-7
Menu Nico's Cajun Island-8
Menu Nico's Cajun Island-8

Salad

Cafe Salad
$11.00
Romaine lettuce, with scallions, red peppers, bababa peppers, mozzarella cheese, provalone cheese, and tomato with your choice of dressing.

Cajun Classics

Blackened Chicken with Bow Tie Pasta
$23.00
Blackened chicken over a bed of bow tie pasta, with cajun ranch cream sauce. Comes with scallions and peppers, and drizzled with blackened bourbon sauce.
Blackened Chicken with Bow Tie Pasta Family Pan
$49.00
Half pan of blackened chicken over a bed of bow tie pasta, with cajun ranch cream sauce. Comes with scallions and peppers, and drizzled with blackened bourbon sauce.
Blackened Chicken Alfredo
$23.00
Backend chicken on a bed of bow tie pasta, in alfredo sauce.
Seafood Pasta
$26.00
Large shrimp and surimi crab in a cajun ranch lobster sauce in bow tie pasta.
Seafood Pasta Family Pan
$55.00
Half pan of large shrimp and surimi crab in a cajun ranch lobster sauce in bow tie pasta.
Black Pepper Pasta
$26.00
Shrimp and andouille sausage in a cajun ranch pepper sauce, with bow tie pasta.
Flame Broiled Bourbon Chicken Bowl
$21.00
Flame broiled bourbon chicken over extra long grain yellow basmati rice topped with blackened bourbon sauce.
Flame Broiled Bourbon Chicken Bowl Family Pan
$49.00
Half pan of flame broiled bourbon chicken over extra long grain yellow basmati rice topped with blackened bourbon sauce.
Crawdad Etouffee
$26.00
Crawdads in a cajun roux sauce, with celery, pepper and onion over extra long grain yellow Basmati rice, with scallions and red peppers.
Blackened Baby Back Ribs
$21.00
Blackened baby back ribs, with blackened bourbon sauce, scallions and red peppers. Comes with a side of Jambalaya.
Fried Chicken Dinner
$19.00
Comes with 4 pieces of fried chicken, along with mashed potatoes and gravy.
10 Piece Fried Chicken
$34.00
Comes with 10 pieces of fried chicken as well as 2 orders of mashed potatoes and gravy.

Dessert

Pecan Pie
$9.00
Cheesecake
$10.00

Drinks

Jarritos
$4.00
Tahitian Treat
$3.00
Pure Leaf Sweet Tea
$5.00

At Nico's Cajun Island, the menu is a celebration of bold, rich flavors that bring the essence of Louisiana straight to your plate. Whether you're craving a comforting plate of pasta, a refreshing salad, or a sweet Southern treat, this place has something that will keep you coming back for more.

Start off with the Cafe Salad, a fresh and crisp option that serves as the perfect prelude to the Cajun feast ahead. But let's be honest—the real stars of the menu are the Cajun Classics. If you're a pasta lover, the Blackened Chicken with Bow Tie Pasta is a must-try, featuring tender, spice-rubbed chicken over perfectly cooked bow tie pasta, all smothered in a creamy, flavorful sauce. If you're feeding a crowd, go for the Blackened Chicken with Bow Tie Pasta Family Pan—the same mouthwatering dish but in a shareable portion.

Seafood fans will love the Seafood Pasta, a rich and indulgent plate loaded with fresh seafood and bathed in a luscious, seasoned sauce that screams Louisiana. And if one plate isn’t enough, the Seafood Pasta Family Pan is the ultimate way to satisfy a group of seafood lovers.

Of course, no meal is complete without dessert. Whether you go for the Pecan Pie, a classic Southern favorite with its gooey, nutty filling, or the Cheesecake, a creamy delight that’s the perfect balance of richness and sweetness, you can’t go wrong.

Pair it all with a refreshing drink like Jarritos, the nostalgic sweetness of Tahitian Treat, or the smooth and satisfying Pure Leaf Sweet Tea. Whatever you choose, Nico’s Cajun Island delivers the bold, comforting flavors of Cajun cuisine in every bite.

Nico's Cajun Island

Experience the best of Cajun cuisine at Nico's Cajun Island located at 1765 Brice Rd Reynoldsburg, OH. Offering a variety of Cajun classics like Blackened Chicken with Bow Tie Pasta and delicious desserts like Pecan Pie and Cheesecake. With options for vegetarians and a welcoming atmosphere for families and groups, Nico's is the ideal spot for lunch and dinner. Call (614) 866-6300 for reservations or delivery.

Follow Us
  • Yelp
  • instagram
  • tripadvisor
Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.